Despite Cultural Indifference

Paul Smoker conducts at the Bop Shop Atrium
Paul Smoker conducts at the Bop Shop Atrium

“Science Fiction” by Ornette Coleman is one of my favorite album and I was thinking about this record last week when Bob Martin posted his top 25 lps on his Facebook page. We named our cat Ornette after seeing Coleman in NYC in 1998. I read in Jeff Spevak’s D&C blog that local trumpet star Paul Smoker and some of his Nazareth College students would perform interpretations of Ornette’s avant-garde classic album, Science Fiction on Sunday afternoon.

I got the lp out this morning so I could look at the liner notes and then I played a few of the tracks from our iTunes library. In Robert (Bob at the time) Palmer’s liner notes he says “Ornette’s music grabs you inside before you understand it intellectually.” That’s certainly how it got me and I still don’t understand it intellectually. He also says “To play this music, you have to step out of the mold your teachers taught you.” But this teacher is Paul Smoker!

So I made arrangements for Peggi to drop me off at the Atrium on the way out to her mom’s place. I sat down next to Greg Bell from “Jazz Rochester” as Paul Smoker introduced the lineup. There was only one Ornette piece in there, “Happy House”, and Paul told the crowd that they would be doing all Ornette later in the month at Nazareth. I had heard that there was a lot of inaccuracies and untruths in the blogospere but didn’t believe it until now. The band sounded great but I gave up some prime painting time to be here and Ornette is one of the few people I would do that for.

There was a discussion panel after the set and Paul Smoker said they would talk about, “Why we do what we do. Why do we keep beating our heads against the wall despite cultural indifference?” I had to leave to meet Peggi out front.

1 Comment

One Reply to “Despite Cultural Indifference”

  1. Hi – noticed your ‘blog posting about Paul. Nice writing, and nice photo!

    Thought you might want to know that I’m playing with Smoker this coming Sunday, March 15, at Lovin’ Cup, 7-9pm. Dave Arenius is also playing; I’m sure you’ve heard him on the local straight-ahead scene, but you might not know that he’s spent some time playing with Anthony Braxton, Roscoe Mitchell, and Archie Shepp.

    (Lovin’ Cup is at 300 Park Point Drive, Rochester; http://www.lovincup.com)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *